Should You Buy a New Construction or Resale Home in Hardin Valley?

Should You Buy a New Construction or Resale Home in Hardin Valley?

  • SHANNON FOSTER-BOLINE
  • 05/17/25

Comparing your options in one of West Knoxville’s fastest-growing neighborhoods.

If you’re house hunting in Hardin Valley, chances are you’ve noticed something: there’s a mix of brand-new homes in developing subdivisions and established homes with a few years (or decades) of character. So, how do you decide which is right for you?

Whether you’re relocating to Knoxville or moving up locally, this post will walk you through the pros and cons of buying new construction versus a resale home in Hardin Valley — so you can feel confident in your decision.

Why Buyers Love New Construction in Hardin Valley

Hardin Valley has seen a boom in new development over the last decade—and for good reason. With its excellent schools, access to Pellissippi Parkway, and proximity to Oak Ridge and Turkey Creek, it's become a hot spot for builders and buyers alike.

Pros of Buying New Construction:

  • Customization Options: In many cases, you can choose finishes, flooring, cabinetry, and even floor plans.

  • Lower Maintenance: New systems, appliances, and roofing mean you likely won’t face major repairs for years.

  • Modern Layouts: Open floor plans, energy-efficient features, and smart home technology are often included.

  • Builder Incentives: Many Hardin Valley builders offer closing cost assistance, appliance packages, or design credits.

Considerations:

  • Construction Timelines: Depending on the phase, you may wait 4–9 months to move in.

  • Upgrades Can Add Up: Base prices don’t always include the features you fall in love with in the model home.

  • Limited Landscaping or Shade: Many new communities are still developing their green space and curb appeal.

Why Resale Homes Still Win for Some Buyers

Hardin Valley’s established neighborhoods—like Covered Bridge, Copperstone, and Fox Creek—offer a different kind of value: mature landscaping, character-filled homes, and built-in community.

Pros of Buying Resale:

  • Established Neighborhood Feel: Mature trees, finished landscaping, and a neighborhood vibe that’s fully developed.

  • Quicker Move-In: You can often close in 30–45 days, making resale homes ideal for buyers on a tight timeline.

  • Potential Cost Savings: In some cases, you'll find more square footage or yard space for the same budget as a smaller new build.

Considerations:

  • Possible Repairs or Updates: Older HVAC, appliances, or cosmetic features may need updating.

  • Less Customization: What you see is what you get (but smart renovations can go a long way).

  • Competitive Offers: Move-in-ready resale homes in Hardin Valley can sell fast—and often attract multiple offers.

Bonus Tip: Always Get an Inspection—Even for New Builds

Even if you're buying a brand-new home, don't skip the inspection. Oversights can happen during any construction project, and a professional inspector can catch issues before they become your responsibility.

So... Which One Is Right for You?

Ultimately, it depends on what matters most to you:

  • Want the latest designs, a low-maintenance lifestyle, and time to wait? New construction might be the best fit.

  • Prefer mature neighborhoods, faster closings, or getting more home for your money? Resale could be the way to go.

Both paths can lead to a great home—you just need the right guide.

 

Ready to explore homes in Hardin Valley?

Whether you’re looking for the perfect new build or a hidden gem with charm, we know Hardin Valley inside and out. Let’s find the right fit for your lifestyle, timeline, and budget.

Start browsing homes here or schedule a buyer consultation to talk through your goals.

Should You Buy a New Construction or Resale Home in Hardin Valley?
Should You Buy a New Construction or Resale Home in Hardin Valley?
Should You Buy a New Construction or Resale Home in Hardin Valley?
SHANNON FOSTER-BOLINE

SHANNON FOSTER-BOLINE

About The Author

About Shannon Foster-Boline

Buying or selling a home is one of the biggest financial decisions most people make — and it deserves thoughtful guidance, not pressure.

I work with Knoxville buyers, sellers, and relocation clients who value strategy, clear communication, and a calm, informed approach. My role isn’t just to open doors or negotiate contracts — it’s to help clients understand their options, anticipate challenges, and move forward with confidence.

With over 1,100 homes sold and more than $270 million in lifetime sales, I bring deep market knowledge and real-world experience to every transaction. I’ve worked with first-time buyers, seasoned homeowners, relocation clients, and luxury sellers — and I tailor my approach to each client’s goals, timeline, and comfort level.

My approach

Clients often describe working with me as steady, thoughtful, and reassuring.

I believe:

  • Strategy matters more than urgency

  • Local market knowledge matters more than national headlines

  • Clear communication reduces stress and leads to better decisions

  • Preparation creates leverage — whether you’re buying or selling

I’m especially experienced in:

  • Relocation and move-up buyers

  • Coordinating buy/sell timelines

  • New construction and modern homes

  • Historic neighborhoods and established communities

  • Navigating complex negotiations calmly and effectively

Experience & leadership

In addition to my work with clients, I’ve been deeply involved in real estate leadership and education throughout East Tennessee. I’ve served in multiple leadership roles within the East Tennessee Realtors and Tennessee Realtors Associations, including President of East Tennessee Realtors.

I hold several advanced designations, including:

  • Certified Residential Specialist (CRS®)

  • Graduate Realtor Institute (GRI®)

  • Accredited Buyer’s Representative (ABR®)

  • Real Estate Negotiation Expert (RENE®)

  • Senior Real Estate Specialist (SRES®)

These credentials reflect my commitment to education, ethics, and professional excellence — but my focus always remains on what matters most to my clients.

Outside of real estate

Outside of work, I’m a mom, a partner, a gardener, and someone who deeply values community and connection.

I love travel, historic architecture, and exploring neighborhoods — both locally and abroad. My family and I split time between Knoxville life and visiting loved ones around the world, experiences that shape how I connect with clients navigating big transitions of their own.

If you’re considering a move

Whether you’re buying, selling, or simply thinking ahead, I believe good decisions start with good information.

If you’d like thoughtful guidance, honest insight, and a calm partner in the process, I’d be honored to help.

Work With Us

We understand the elements of the individual needs and the unique process of each transaction. At the end of the day, we want you to walk away feeling that you have received an amazing experience with our team and that you have been able to realize your dream of selling or buying a home!

Follow Us on Instagram